| #1 Magma[47553] |
| ppp-234.tnt-2.nhv.smartworld.net |
| 1st Comment, enjoy my report! Comments Welcomed. |
| #2 kek[47557] |
| cx110054-a.pwy1.sdca.home.com |
| kek |
| #3 probe[47560] |
| 242849hfc161.tampabay.rr.com |
very good html and pictures, however, the players were both newbies which kinda made it gay:(
imagine good skills with html and pics.... on 2 good players
10 10 10 ! |
| #4 probe[47561] |
| 242849hfc161.tampabay.rr.com |
| 8 |
#5  [47566] |
| csdi2-proxy.support.compaq.com |
Well written report. Although had didn't have much text to read on, your format was nice. A zerg vs zerg game, there really isn't any tricks so there isn't much to comment on.
Maybe next time either include more details anything you can to get a larger amount of text, or BR a different race matchup. Most of your text was the beginning part before the game even started. You don't want this. But it was still a good report.
7
Fox^1 |
| #6 [47567] |
| csdi2-proxy.support.compaq.com |
I changed my mind.
8
Fox^1 |
| #7 Magma[47572] |
| ppp-234.tnt-2.nhv.smartworld.net |
If only i could get some gosu players, sigh......
Thanks for the input, ill try to get some real players =/. |
| #8 Elendale[47577] |
| AC8CAA33.ipt.aol.com |
WOW! Looks impressive. I like. Go bother NH lamers for better players... wait, don't... heheh... Good work
-Elendale |
| #9 rabid fox[47578] |
| spider-ti064.proxy.aol.com |
for the picts of the build ordres, used the finished buildings instead of the incomlete morphed zerg strucures
i don't want to have to read the good reports, just look at the pictures |
| #10 ...[47581] |
| adsl-63-200-51-196.dsl.snfc21.pacbell.net |
| good format. i give it two asses up. |
| #11 BW-sux[47583] |
| spider-wj053.proxy.aol.com |
One of the better reports here, although when you announced the races were Zerg and Zerg, I thought it would be a boring game. The build orders were a little confusing to follow for me. As for the rest of it, well it was great!
8 BW-sux |
| #12 Master-chef[47588] |
| AC99AC33.ipt.aol.com |
Outstanding job on the report. I loved the layout and pix.
I juss love reports where the pix could juss tell you the story, and this did (im a lazy fat chef =).
<font size"20">8</font>
Chef |
| #13 The Asylum[47592] |
| ce-stjh-01-02-e0.cbl.nf.net |
Better players, better players!
But besides for that great job. The writing was impeccable, easy to follow, and the HTML and pics were very well-done. Just a tip, but some people prefer pics of the scores to written copies of them, whether they are in tables or not(I'm not one of them tho).
-Not great players
-Lack of any significant humor :(
+Good writing
+Great HTML and Pics
<u>+Easy to follow report</u>
I believe a 7-9 rating, depending on how much the quality of the player affects the final rating. Great job though. We seem to be getting a lot of good reports lately. |
| #14 TZ[47610] |
| 212.143.87.162 |
Good report , bad game . Happens too often lately . People should stop reporting NH and small clan games . Differ is NH try to act kali and trash talk while small clans really miss the witty trash talking .
Have a nice day
TZ |
| #15 SiegeTank[47647] |
| 145.44.70.40 |
| It was cool. Looked good, although the game sucked ass. Too bad. I'd give it an 8. |
| #16 -xdragon-[47658] |
| 209.67.161.34 |
Wow... if I read correctly, there are zero skirmish of units. This is the first time I read race to kill off building when both side have actually significant amount of troops.
Anyway, nicely done graphics, easy to follow storyline, just that there is not much story to tell. I'd give it an 8 tho, just for the eyecandies :) |
| #17 <font color=yellow>Phoenix</font>[47682] |
| node156e4.a2000.nl |
Good Job
I'll give my usual comments, some of which might have been said yet.
<ul>
<li>Not even a single fight before the last battle, making it a bad game to BR.
<li>Build orders with a pic only are confusing. I guess they had relatively sane build orders (though second hatch at natural before pool isn't really sane..).
<li>I had to highlight the scores to see them (or is that just me?)
<li>Graphics were nice. Maybe too many (is that possible) compared to the amount of text.
</ul>
In all, very nice BR
I give you a
<font color=blue size=5>7.5</font>
Phoenix |
| #18 Glorious_HT[47710] |
| utfc2.utfors.se |
Cool game. It´s the second time I´ve read a race-to-raise (how do you spell the freckin´ word?)
game.
8.32649659652
hmm... lets just say 9 =)
Glorious_HT |
| #19 blah[47717] |
| 63.210.199.30 |
it's "raze".
and magma - this reported looked really nice. but i have to agree about the quality of the battle. not that the players were newbies (which I don't think they were), but more so that there was only one battle. Race to raze br's are cool, but I'd rather have them after some intense skirmishing. instead of 1) build up, 2) do a first attack 3) win. (-:
I'd give it an 8 which should be the highest score given to so-so games. (-: 9 and 10's should be reserved for reports that looked this nice and involved some intense battles.
very nice though. |
| #20 Magma[47771] |
| ppp-150.tnt-1.nhv.smartworld.net |
I cant seem to get any good players =/ and the players in -x17 shun me =(. Also, I have noticed that the score
tables dont show in netscape, no idea why. Thanks fer all the comments, As for now, i'm off to find a good game. |
| #21 -=-Dr.J-=-[47963] |
| adsl-207-105-255-146.dsl.lsan03.pacbell.net |
| I think that you should choose your games to report more wisely. PIck interesting games. Dont submit just any report. but anyways i like your layout and pic strategy. Just more text please and make things funn: ) |
| #22 Shepherd[48109] |
| cm-24-161-50-205.nycap.rr.com |
Oooooo A CLOSE GAME!
I like games that are REALLY close. . .but too bad there's ONLY one battle in the whole game.
Best games tend to have frequent skirmishes to test each other's ablities. |
Home
Forum
Starcraft Tournaments
