| #1 +SecretAznMan+[53369] |
| proxy3-external.rdc1.bc.home.com |
| 1st |
| #2 $h@dow[53370] |
| pdx-ppp102.pop1.net |
| Sorry about the inconvience with opening the other page. Not everyone may do it but the MIDI's really add. I tried many times to be able to just click on this webpage but failed and went to my last resort. Try following the words of my song with the first MIDI and you may get it more. |
| #3 $h@dow[53371] |
| pdx-ppp102.pop1.net |
| I JUST posted it and write a comment and still don't get first. Shows how many people come to this site. |
| #4 $h@dow[53372] |
| pdx-ppp102.pop1.net |
| I'm sorry I messed up on my name a little bit. On a previous post I put $hadow and on this I put $h@dow. I'm sorry about this but I'm the same person. I just want them both to be the same. My name should actually be $h@dow instead of $hadow on the previous post. Maybe if you could change it to $h@dow on the previous post that would be cool. Thanks, and sorry I always seem to mess up on some little thing during my post even though I preview it many times. |
| #5 Siege-[53373] |
| 145.44.70.122 |
1st after Author :)
Protoss guy = dumbshit. Who's ever going to attack Zerg colonies when you can take out spires or drones? Magical word in this game: REAVERDROP. HT's would have done too.
Air battles suck. Scouts suck. At least Scouts with no corsair backup suck... |
| #6 <marquee>Smoke</marquee>[53374] |
| cache01.syd.optusnet.com.au |
This report sucked on account of:
1) Map.
2) Players.
3) Gayness of game. |
| #7 Bloodcry[53378] |
| click-cl4-cache2.ilford.mdip.bt.net |
Silly game in the first place...
reavers vs zerg air? I think not...
HT much better... imagine storming all the devs, guardians, and mutas... or perhaps maelstorm then psi storm... (seldom got chance to use maelstorm)
sorry to say this but, the game sucks cause of the newb turtles on bloodbath. I hate turtles, and the way they are playing it, as if it was bgh. Report was alrite... game sucks.
(try playing 4 ffa zerg on blood bath, truly the name fits)
|
| #8 ~Scorba~[53380] |
| 213.20.165.240 |
could have been a nice report but the players were indeed using some sort of... strange strats.
choose some no-newbies next time for a real report!! |
| #9 BackStabingLiar[53389] |
| 63.239.42.130 |
<html>
<body>
<font color=blue><b>I was one of the people telling you to shut up and stop when you were bitching about your last rating, but now i hope you see why. This report was better than your last. Now i think you deserve a 7 or MAYBE a 8. Better players and i would say 8. But youre obviously still not at the 9-10 level. This is exactly the kind of report that is somewhere between, and is why you needed to get a lower rating on your previous report.
So, GJ nice improvement, IMO, and keep improving. Just try to watch better players.
peace
</b></font>
</body>
</html> |
| #10 BW-sux[53391] |
| spider-wj023.proxy.aol.com |
Don't play blood bath.
5
BW-sux |
| #11 Hostile~SCV[53405] |
| spider-tk012.proxy.aol.com |
This is nowhere near an 8. Compare it to other 8 reports (like my Winter FFA, the Dref-the-hacker story, BW-Sux's recent one) and you'll see what I mean.
You have to work on that grammar. The music was pointless and BRing a game between 2 Turtles is just... wrong.
A Gold report is supposed to be an achievement (sp?), and this report didn't achieve much. Therefore, I give it a 6.5.
The Hoss Bot |
| #12 blah[53407] |
| 63.210.199.30 |
6.5
seeing all those sunkens made me think of dref's bgh strats of the day... except this wasn't a humor br....
Pure dev against carriers? Pure dev sucks. They lose to almost everything with that horrible horrible horrible cooldown. Devs are supposed to be used with other units (esp mutas)
Your images have potential, but they can use some work. |
| #13 playboybunny[53411] |
| 216.163.143.130 |
| you guys are way too harsh on your ratings -- i give this a solid 8.0 -- nowhere hear a 6.5. I am plad you don't grade my essays =) |
| #14 playboybunny[53412] |
| 216.163.143.130 |
| plad=glad |
| #15 $h@dow[53413] |
| pdx-ppp126.pop1.net |
| I always seem to get the crappy games, and I know its not a good enough game for a 9 or a 10, i'm not asking that. I just tried my best to make a bad game seem good. Has anyone even listened to the MIDIS? |
| #16 $h@dow[53414] |
| pdx-ppp126.pop1.net |
| Hostile-SCV I compared my other 6 report to other reports but I seemed to get flamed for doing that and now you are saying to compare this with other 8 reports and see how it dosn't deserve an 8. Well I think this report was better than my last and yes maybe a gold report is supposed to be an achievement but people are getting them all the time. Nobody ever BR's a game for me so I have to BR friends or do other things. Maybe my rating would go up if I BR'ed a better game because I tried my best on this one. |
| #17 Presto[53420] |
| 1Cust79.tnt4.grapevine.tx.da.uu.net |
| lol the turtle story was good the br was good but the game sucked... keep up the goood work and the music made it all worth reading:) hehe |
| #18 Ashdate[53443] |
| nat214.245.mpoweredpc.net |
I think the problem wasn't the turtlers so much as how the Protoss player didn't adapt very well. High Templar would have owned the Zerg air, as would Reavers wrecked as well. Plus, when you have scouts, and they're inside a base, with nothign stopping them, why the hell are you NOT killing drones/overlords/spire??? Also d-web would have done wonders.
Also, WHY didn't anybody in these games.. I dunno.. drop in the opponents base???? It seems to me a few hydras/lings or zealots/goons would have done wonders in wrecking the economy.
|
| #19 IamCanadian[53448] |
| cr467192-a.slnt1.on.wave.home.com |
R D G
E R W
A O
V P
E
R
^^
|
| #20 a[W]o_Stilicho[53449] |
| KRLDA010-1022.splitrock.net |
Nice job. Graphics were cool.
I mean, come on guys... this took more time to make than lemon merangue pie! Actually, does that take very long? Mmm.... pie. That BR actually sucked becuase it lacked pie. |
| #21 <font color=orage>Phoenix-S-</font>[53454] |
| r-177.105.alltel.net |
<font color=orage>This report sucked badly. The writing sucked, theimages sucked, the HTML sucked, the players sucked, and the game sucked.
<center><h1><font color=red>5</font></h1></center> |
#22  [53459] |
| inehou-pxy02.compaq.com |
The game was lacking, and so were the players. All those sunkens and cannons tell me that. But other then that you did a decent job, your getting better and I am sure that you will be getting higher ratings soon enough.
7
Fox^1 |
| #23 Hostile~SCV[53488] |
| spider-wm058.proxy.aol.com |
Dude, I will play a game for you if you're that desperate for a "good" player. most people in NH or -x17 will let you watch a game.
If I was rating it, I wouldn't rate it higher than an 8, even if it was a great game, because of grammar/sp, nothing creative with the images, etc.
I've gotten consistent 8's in my only 3 BR's, but I've made adequate improvement. I expect my next BR to score in the 8.5-9 range, since the amount of my improvement could put me up to the next "level." There is no need to whine if you know that you, yourself, are improving.
And, as a sidenote.... Retaliate with better grammar plz, good work.
The Hoss Bot |
| #24 ProtectorOfChar[53534] |
| t5o55p61.telia.com |
I admit that the game itself sucked but he did his best with
the stuff he had. If you had reported that game you shouldn´t have done very well either. He turned somthing useless into somthing much better and that is good I think.
So I give this guy 8 coz he did what he could. Nice work.
8
ProtectorOfChar |
| #25 Shepherd[53568] |
| cm-24-161-48-217.nycap.rr.com |
I had to LAUGH hard in this BR.
The map sucked, yeah, but I couldn't believe that this guy went carriers on BloodBath. Just think! Mass carriers on small map. . .that's only too funny.
But. . .I don't like mass carriers at all tho. However, I must admit that I enjoyed this BR a bit. |
| #26 Hostile~SCV[53628] |
| spider-tf084.proxy.aol.com |
So I still get 8's, yet the games I've BRed thus far are good & I put more effort into it? Riiiiiiiiiiiight.
ah well, TX-0 got a 9 on that one POS, some people just put too much crack in their daily appetite. |
| #27 $h@dow[53676] |
| dsl-1-93.bmi.net |
| Thnx Hostile SCV, yeah i'll BR a game on your sometime. It does take a while, for me probably longer than others. I did it over 3 days, 1-2 hours each day because I took a crapload of images. A good BR can take many hours because you have to remember the timeline of the whole game. Still a fictional one you can just make stuff up as you go. I'm glad I got a 7 on this, meaning I improved from my last report. Some of this stuff was meant to be as funny too, but I don't have a great sense of humor. To anyone who says it flat out sucked I suggest you make a battlereport and then when someone says yours is bad you'll probably get mad too. |
| #28 $h@dow[53680] |
| dsl-1-93.bmi.net |
| I just learned for a half year a lot about grammar in advanced english so maybe what I need to do is edit the thing more. Still I doubt some grammar mistakes in this situation would have them lower me a point, if it did then DOH. |
| #29 JawaAvenger[54062] |
| d6-22.hntnny.optonline.net |
Pretty much what everyone else said, Good BR, Good Writer, Bad Map, and SUCK ASS PLAYERS!
No rush? WTF IS THAT?!?! Blood Bath? Come on! BR decent people plz, or at least halfway decent people like me. 8) Well... maybe a third decent. BR a Nohunters game, and you'll get an 8. |
| #30 $h@dow[54163] |
| pdx-ppp451.pop1.net |
| Next time I go into nohunters and look for a game to BR i'll ask and most people will probably say no. I'll ask but most people don't say much. |
Home
Forum
Starcraft Tournaments
